By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

In "One Nation Always Under God: Profiles in Christian Courage," Senator Tim Scott endeavors to weave a narrative asserting that Christianity has been the cornerstone of America's greatness. He presents a series of biographical sketches of American Christians whose faith-driven actions, he argues, have significantly shaped the nation's history. ([barnesandnoble.com](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/one-nation-always-under-god-tim-scott/1147516957?utm_source=openai))

Scott's selection of figures is commendable, featuring individuals like abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison, Apollo 13 astronaut Jim Lovell, mental health reformer Dorothea Dix, World War I ace Eddie Rickenbacker, and agronomist Norman Borlaug. These profiles are intended to exemplify the American spirit of adventure and the Christian commitment to serving others. ([barnesandnoble.com](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/one-nation-always-under-god-tim-scott/1147516957?utm_source=openai))

However, the book's overarching thesis—that Christian values have been the singular driving force behind America's innovation, prosperity, and moral leadership—feels overly simplistic and reductive. While faith undoubtedly played a role in the lives of many historical figures, attributing the nation's achievements solely to Christian principles overlooks the complex interplay of diverse influences, including secular philosophies, scientific advancements, and contributions from various cultural and religious backgrounds.

Moreover, Scott's assertion that secularism and moral relativism are eroding America's foundational values comes across as alarmist and lacks nuanced analysis. The book tends to romanticize the past, glossing over historical injustices and the struggles of marginalized groups whose experiences do not fit neatly into the narrative of a nation uniformly guided by Christian virtue.

Stylistically, the prose is accessible but occasionally veers into didacticism, with Scott's political perspectives permeating the text. This approach may resonate with readers who share his viewpoints but could alienate those seeking a more balanced exploration of America's historical tapestry.

In conclusion, while "One Nation Always Under God" offers some inspiring stories of individuals whose faith influenced their contributions to society, it falls short as a comprehensive historical analysis. The book's narrow focus and lack of critical engagement with the complexities of American history render it a limited resource for readers seeking a deeper understanding of the nation's development.

Recommendation: Read with caution.

written on: 8/14/2025