By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

In "Where We Keep the Light: Stories from a Life of Service," Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, with the assistance of journalist Emily Jane Fox, presents a memoir that is as much a political manifesto as it is a personal narrative. The book endeavors to illuminate Shapiro's journey through public service, underscored by his Jewish faith and a commitment to bipartisan cooperation.

Shapiro's narrative is replete with anecdotes that showcase his dedication to public service. From his early days as a county commissioner to his tenure as the state's attorney general and eventual rise to the governorship, he portrays himself as a pragmatic leader focused on "getting stuff done." This catchphrase, emblematic of his approach, resonates throughout the memoir, emphasizing his belief in action over rhetoric. ([washingtonpost.com](https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2026/01/26/josh-shapiro-memoir-where-we-keep-light-review/?utm_source=openai))

A significant portion of the memoir delves into Shapiro's Jewish identity and how it has shaped his political and personal life. He candidly discusses the challenges and prejudices he has faced, particularly in the political arena. Notably, he recounts a disconcerting episode during the vetting process for the vice-presidential candidacy, where he was subjected to questions that insinuated dual loyalty due to his faith. Such experiences underscore the persistent undercurrents of antisemitism in American politics. ([washingtonpost.com](https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2026/01/26/josh-shapiro-memoir-where-we-keep-light-review/?utm_source=openai))

However, the memoir is not without its shortcomings. While Shapiro emphasizes his bipartisan efforts and moral clarity, the book often skirts around providing substantive policy discussions. The narrative leans heavily on personal anecdotes and moral reflections, leaving readers yearning for a deeper understanding of his policy positions and legislative achievements. This omission is particularly glaring given the current political climate, where voters are increasingly seeking concrete solutions to pressing issues.

Furthermore, the memoir's timing and tone suggest a strategic move to bolster Shapiro's national profile, possibly in anticipation of a future presidential bid. While it's not uncommon for politicians to pen memoirs as a prelude to higher office, the lack of depth in policy discourse makes this endeavor feel more like a calculated political maneuver than a genuine introspection.

In conclusion, "Where We Keep the Light" offers a glimpse into Josh Shapiro's life and values, highlighting his commitment to service and faith. However, its deficiency in substantive policy discussion and its overtly strategic undertones render it a less compelling read for those seeking depth and authenticity.

Recommendation: Read with caution.

written on: 2/7/2026