NOT MY TYPE
By E. Jean Carroll
Publisher: St. Martin's
The journalist shares moments from her life and the two trials in which she accused President Trump of sexual assault and defamation.
Review by By The Books Reviewer
E. Jean Carroll's memoir, "What Do We Need Men For?: A Modest Proposal," is a whirlwind tour through the author's life, punctuated by encounters with a series of men she dubs "hideous." Carroll, known for her sharp wit and unflinching honesty, embarks on a road trip across America, reflecting on her experiences and those of the women she meets along the way.
The book is structured around Carroll's list of "hideous men," a catalog that includes a television publicist who attacked her in her car, a mob boss in Chicago, and even a rapist and serial killer who approached her at her home. These accounts are interspersed with tales of other women's experiences, painting a grim picture of the pervasive nature of male predation. As Megan Garber notes in The Atlantic, "There’s much more, as Carroll drives and remembers; the thing about a list is that it will keep on going until the list itself decides it is finished." ([theatlantic.com](https://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2019/07/e-jean-carroll-what-do-we-need-men-for-memoir-review/593245/?utm_source=openai))
Carroll's writing is both cheery and harrowing, a juxtaposition that underscores the absurdity and horror of the situations she describes. Her eccentric personality shines through, from her polka-dotted Prius named Miss Bingley to her poodle rescue named Lewis Carroll. This quirkiness serves as a form of resistance, a declaration that she will not be diminished by the men who have wronged her.
However, the book is not without its flaws. The episodic nature of the narrative can feel disjointed at times, and the sheer number of accounts may overwhelm readers. Additionally, while Carroll's humor is a coping mechanism, it can sometimes undercut the gravity of the situations she describes.
In conclusion, "What Do We Need Men For?" is a compelling and thought-provoking read that sheds light on the pervasive nature of male predation. Carroll's unique voice and unflinching honesty make this memoir a valuable contribution to the conversation about gender and power dynamics. Highly recommended!
Recommendation: Highly recommended!
written on: 6/26/2025