THE STEAL
By Alex Wagner
Publisher: Flatiron
The host of the podcast Runaway Country profiles a handful of conservatives whose efforts during the Reagan administration impacted the American judiciary.
Review by By The Books Reviewer
Alex Wagner's "The Steal: Four Right-Wing Hard-Liners, One Republican Presidency, and the Raid on America's Courts" is a meticulously researched exposé that delves into the calculated efforts of conservative operatives to reshape the American judiciary. Wagner, a seasoned journalist and political analyst, brings her investigative prowess to bear on this critical examination of political maneuvering that has had lasting impacts on the nation's legal landscape.
The narrative centers on four pivotal figures: Ed Meese, Paul Weyrich, Joe Coors, and Robert Bork. Wagner meticulously details how these individuals, leveraging their positions and resources, orchestrated a strategic campaign during Ronald Reagan's presidency to install conservative judges who would influence American jurisprudence for generations. The book sheds light on the clandestine meetings, ideological battles, and the formation of influential organizations like The Federalist Society, which played a significant role in this judicial transformation.
Wagner's writing is both engaging and informative, striking a balance between journalistic rigor and compelling storytelling. She provides a comprehensive account of the political strategies employed, supported by extensive research and interviews. This approach not only informs but also captivates the reader, making complex political maneuvers accessible and understandable.
Critics have lauded "The Steal" for its insightful analysis and relevance to current judicial dynamics. Library Journal describes it as a "fascinating history" that aids readers in understanding how past events are mirrored in today's judicial decisions. Kirkus Reviews praises it as a "penetrating look at how a political fringe makes itself mainstream through force of law." Jon Favreau, co-founder of Crooked Media, commends Wagner for writing the "origin story of the decades-long plot to capture the courts," highlighting its meticulous and infuriating nature.
However, some readers might find the book's detailed account of political strategies and legal intricacies challenging. The depth of information, while commendable, may overwhelm those less familiar with the subject matter. Additionally, the book's focus on conservative figures and their strategies might be perceived as lacking a balanced perspective, potentially alienating readers seeking a more bipartisan analysis.
In conclusion, "The Steal" is a compelling and essential read for anyone interested in understanding the historical underpinnings of the current conservative dominance in the American judiciary. Wagner's thorough research and engaging narrative provide valuable insights into the strategic efforts that have shaped the nation's legal system. While the book's depth may be daunting for some, its revelations are crucial for comprehending the ongoing debates surrounding judicial appointments and decisions. Highly recommended!
Recommendation: Highly recommended!
written on: 9/24/2026