By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

John U. Bacon's "The Gales of November" is a masterful and meticulously researched account of the tragic sinking of the SS Edmund Fitzgerald on November 10, 1975. Bacon, renowned for his narrative prowess, delves deep into the heart of this maritime disaster, offering readers an immersive experience that transcends mere historical recounting.

The book opens with a comprehensive overview of the Great Lakes, emphasizing their treacherous nature and the formidable challenges they pose to even the most seasoned mariners. Bacon's vivid descriptions of the lakes' unpredictable weather patterns and the sheer power of their storms set a foreboding tone, effectively foreshadowing the calamity to come.

Central to Bacon's narrative is the Edmund Fitzgerald itself—a 729-foot behemoth that symbolized America's industrial might during the post-World War II era. Through meticulous research, Bacon reconstructs the ship's final voyage, providing a day-by-day, and at times hour-by-hour, account of the events leading up to its untimely demise. He skillfully interweaves technical details about the ship's design and the environmental factors at play, creating a suspenseful buildup that keeps readers on edge.

One of the book's most commendable aspects is its humanization of the tragedy. Bacon draws on over 100 interviews with the families, friends, and former crewmates of the 29 men who perished, painting intimate portraits that honor their lives and sacrifices. This approach not only adds depth to the narrative but also ensures that the victims are remembered as individuals, not just statistics.

Critics have lauded Bacon's work for its depth and narrative style. Kirkus Reviews describes it as a "gripping account of a maritime disaster," highlighting Bacon's ability to deliver biographies of crewmen, detailed descriptions of the storm, and interviews with victims' families. ([kirkusreviews.com](https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/john-u-bacon/the-gales-of-november/?utm_source=openai)) Filmmaker Ken Burns praises the book as "another riveting narrative that puts facts on a still mesmerizing legend," emphasizing Bacon's success in distilling the essence of the story. ([johnubacon.com](https://johnubacon.com/the-gales-of-november/?utm_source=openai))

However, while the book is undeniably comprehensive, some readers might find the extensive technical details and the sheer volume of information overwhelming. Bacon's commitment to thoroughness, while commendable, occasionally slows the narrative's pace. Yet, for those with a keen interest in maritime history and the intricacies of Great Lakes shipping, these details provide invaluable context.

In conclusion, "The Gales of November" stands as a definitive account of the Edmund Fitzgerald disaster. Bacon's meticulous research, combined with his narrative flair, results in a compelling read that honors the memory of the lost crew and sheds light on a pivotal moment in maritime history. This book is highly recommended for history enthusiasts, maritime aficionados, and anyone seeking a profound exploration of human resilience in the face of nature's fury.

Recommendation: Highly recommended!

written on: 10/16/2025