By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

Nate Bargatze's debut literary endeavor, "Big Dumb Eyes: Stories from a Simpler Mind," attempts to transpose his celebrated stand-up comedy into the written word. Known for his droll, self-deprecating humor that thrives in live performances, Bargatze faces the formidable challenge of capturing the same comedic impact on the page.

The book is a collection of personal anecdotes and reflections, ranging from tales of his first car, a clunky Mazda named Old Blue with a tennis ball for a stick shift, to humorous accounts of his upbringing in Old Hickory, Tennessee. One standout chapter, "My Sister the Alien," recounts a chaotic family incident where Bargatze and his father forget to bring his sister home from church, leading to a series of amusing events. These stories, while entertaining, often lack the punch that Bargatze's live delivery provides. The written format seems to constrain the spontaneity and timing that are hallmarks of his stand-up routines.

Bargatze himself acknowledges his aversion to reading and, presumably, writing books, hinting at commercial motivations behind the project. This self-awareness adds a layer of charm but also raises questions about the book's purpose and authenticity. While dedicated fans may find enjoyment in these pages, newcomers might struggle to grasp the full appeal of Bargatze's humor without the context of his live performances.

In conclusion, "Big Dumb Eyes" offers a light, quick read with moments of genuine amusement. However, it falls short of delivering the consistent laugh-out-loud experience that fans of Bargatze's stand-up have come to expect. For those unfamiliar with his work, this book may serve as a gentle introduction, but it is unlikely to capture the full essence of his comedic talent.

Recommendation: Read with caution.

written on: 5/15/2025