By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

In "My Good Side," Scheana Shay, renowned for her tenure on Bravo's "Vanderpump Rules," endeavors to present a candid memoir that traverses her journey from a Southern California upbringing to the tumultuous world of reality television. While the book offers glimpses into Shay's personal and professional life, it often falls into the trap of superficiality, leaving readers yearning for deeper introspection.

Shay's narrative begins with her early years, highlighting her experiences as a studious overachiever who faced bullying and grappled with her Mexican heritage. These formative experiences, as detailed in the Kirkus Reviews, set the stage for her later pursuits in Hollywood. However, the memoir's recounting of these events lacks the depth and nuance that would allow readers to fully empathize with her struggles.

The transition to her Hollywood career is marked by a series of relationships with notable figures, including Eddie Cibrian, John Mayer, and Jesse Metcalfe. While these anecdotes might pique the interest of celebrity gossip enthusiasts, they are presented in a manner that feels more like a checklist of encounters rather than insightful reflections on personal growth or the complexities of navigating relationships in the public eye.

Shay's tenure on "Vanderpump Rules" is, unsurprisingly, a focal point of the memoir. She sheds light on the behind-the-scenes dynamics of the show, acknowledging the editing and packaging that shape the final product. Yet, despite this acknowledgment, the narrative often reads as an extension of the show's drama, lacking the critical distance that would provide a more profound understanding of the reality TV industry and its impact on personal identity.

One of the more commendable aspects of "My Good Side" is Shay's openness about her struggles with fertility, pregnancy loss, and Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). These sections offer a glimpse into her vulnerabilities and the challenges she has faced beyond the camera's lens. However, as noted in the Library Journal review, the memoir's treatment of these topics is factual and without fanfare, which, while honest, may leave readers desiring a more profound exploration of these deeply personal experiences.

Stylistically, the memoir is accessible, with Shay's voice coming through as effervescent and engaging. Yet, this breezy tone often undermines the gravity of the subjects she addresses, resulting in a narrative that skims the surface rather than delving into the complexities of her life and career.

In conclusion, "My Good Side" offers a cursory glance into Scheana Shay's life, punctuated by celebrity encounters and reality TV drama. While it may satisfy die-hard fans of "Vanderpump Rules," those seeking a more profound and introspective memoir will likely find it lacking. The book's potential is evident, but it ultimately falls short of delivering the depth and insight that would elevate it beyond a mere recounting of events.

Recommendation: Read with caution.

written on: 7/31/2025