WE THE PEOPLE
By Jill Lepore
Publisher: Liveright
The author of “These Truths” examines the history of the U.S. Constitution and challenges its interpretation by the Supreme Court and the theory of originalism.
Review by By The Books Reviewer
Jill Lepore's "We the People: A History of the U.S. Constitution" is an audacious and meticulously researched examination of America's foundational document. Lepore, a distinguished historian and law professor at Harvard, embarks on a formidable journey to dissect the Constitution's evolution, its intended flexibility, and the alarming rigidity that has stifled its amendment process in recent decades.
At the heart of Lepore's thesis is the contention that the framers designed the Constitution to be a living document, amenable to change as the nation evolved. She argues that the current paralysis in amending the Constitution is a betrayal of this original intent, leading to a reliance on judicial interpretation and executive action to effect change—methods that circumvent the democratic process and concentrate power in the hands of a few. ([washingtonpost.com](https://www.washingtonpost.com/books/2025/09/12/we-people-constitution-amendments-jill-lepore-review/?utm_source=openai))
Lepore's narrative is both comprehensive and compelling, weaving together historical analysis with contemporary relevance. She delves into the successes and failures of various amendment efforts, from the ratification of the Bill of Rights to the thwarted Equal Rights Amendment, illustrating the challenges inherent in the amendment process. Her critique of originalism is particularly scathing; she dismantles the notion that the Constitution should be interpreted solely through the lens of its 18th-century framers, highlighting the dangers of such a static approach in a dynamic society. ([agrolatam.com](https://www.agrolatam.com/news/jill-lepore-we-the-people-constitution-originalism/?utm_source=openai))
However, the book is not without its shortcomings. Lepore's exhaustive detail, while impressive, can be overwhelming, potentially alienating readers seeking a more concise analysis. Moreover, her impassioned arguments occasionally veer into polemic, which may detract from the scholarly objectivity expected in such a work.
In conclusion, "We the People" is a provocative and essential read for those interested in the past, present, and future of American constitutionalism. Lepore's erudition and eloquence shine through, offering a clarion call for a reinvigoration of the amendment process to ensure the Constitution remains a true reflection of the people's will. While the book's density may challenge some readers, its insights are well worth the effort.
Final recommendation: Highly recommended!
Recommendation: Highly recommended!
written on: 9/25/2025