By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

Christine Brennan's "On Her Game: Caitlin Clark and the Revolution in Women's Sports" is an ambitious attempt to chronicle the meteoric rise of basketball sensation Caitlin Clark. However, despite Brennan's esteemed reputation as a sports journalist, this work falls disappointingly short of delivering a compelling and insightful narrative.

The book's primary flaw lies in its overreliance on superficial accolades and a lack of critical depth. Brennan inundates readers with a barrage of press conference quotes and generic praise, failing to provide the nuanced analysis that a subject of Clark's caliber warrants. This approach results in a narrative that feels more like a hastily assembled highlight reel than a thoughtful exploration of an athlete's journey.

Moreover, Brennan's portrayal of Clark borders on hagiography. The author seems enamored with her subject to the point of neglecting any meaningful examination of the challenges and controversies that have accompanied Clark's ascent. This one-dimensional depiction not only undermines the book's credibility but also does a disservice to readers seeking a balanced perspective.

The writing itself is another point of contention. Brennan's prose is often pedestrian, lacking the vivid descriptions and engaging storytelling that could have brought Clark's story to life. Instead, readers are subjected to a monotonous recitation of events, devoid of the emotional resonance that characterizes superior sports biographies.

In summary, "On Her Game" is a missed opportunity. While the subject matter holds immense potential, Brennan's execution is lackluster and uninspired. Readers interested in Caitlin Clark's impact on women's sports would be better served seeking out more substantive and critically engaging accounts.

Final Recommendation: Not recommended.

Recommendation: Not recommended.

written on: 7/17/2025