By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

Mayci Neeley's memoir, "Told You So," is a raw and unflinching account of a young woman's tumultuous journey through love, loss, and self-discovery. Known from TikTok and Hulu's "The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives," Neeley delves into her personal experiences with a candor that is both refreshing and, at times, unsettling.

The narrative begins with a harrowing account of the day Neeley learned of her boyfriend's tragic death—a moment that sets the tone for the emotional depth of the book. From there, she recounts her upbringing in a strict Mormon household, her struggles with the rigid expectations of her faith, and the challenges she faced as a young mother navigating the complexities of single parenthood.

Neeley's writing is brutally honest, often laying bare the raw emotions associated with her experiences. She does not shy away from discussing the darker aspects of her life, including an abusive relationship and the internal conflict between her religious beliefs and personal desires. This level of transparency is commendable and offers readers a genuine glimpse into her world.

However, the memoir is not without its shortcomings. Some readers have noted that the book lacks a clear narrative arc, making it feel more like a series of disjointed anecdotes rather than a cohesive story. Additionally, while Neeley's honesty is appreciated, there are moments where the writing feels unpolished, possibly due to a lack of editorial refinement. As one reviewer aptly put it, "I loved hearing her story, I hate how dirty her editor did her." ([app.thestorygraph.com](https://app.thestorygraph.com/book_reviews/fbadddf5-dd07-45b6-8b91-765324c89e10?utm_source=openai))

Furthermore, the memoir touches on significant events, such as the "MomTok" drama, but these are often glossed over, leaving readers wanting more depth and insight. This superficial treatment of certain topics may leave some feeling unsatisfied.

In conclusion, "Told You So" is a courageous endeavor by Mayci Neeley to share her life's trials and triumphs. While the memoir offers valuable insights into the challenges of balancing personal identity with religious expectations, its lack of narrative cohesion and editorial polish detract from its overall impact. Readers seeking an unfiltered account of a woman's resilience may find value in this book, but those looking for a well-structured and finely edited memoir might be disappointed.

Recommendation: Read with caution.

written on: 10/16/2025