By The Book Reviews

Review by By The Books Reviewer

Charles Spencer's memoir, "Swan Song: Diana, My Sister," is a perplexing amalgamation of heartfelt tribute and unabashed score-settling. While it purports to offer an intimate portrait of the late Princess Diana, it often devolves into a platform for Spencer's personal grievances, overshadowing the very subject it aims to honor.

The book does provide touching recollections of Diana's early life, painting a picture of a spirited and compassionate individual. Spencer's anecdotes about their shared childhood experiences are genuinely moving, offering glimpses into the bond they shared. However, these moments are frequently interrupted by Spencer's relentless airing of personal vendettas. His disparaging remarks about various members of the royal family, including King Charles III, whom he describes as a "bellowing buffoon," come across as petty and self-serving. Such characterizations not only detract from the book's credibility but also raise questions about the author's motives.

One of the most contentious claims is Spencer's assertion that King Charles reacted with "giddy elation" upon learning of Diana's death, allegedly stating, "we'll forget her soon enough." This accusation has been met with strong rebuttals from Buckingham Palace, emphasizing the potential distortions of memory influenced by grief. The inclusion of such incendiary allegations, without substantial corroboration, undermines the memoir's integrity.

Furthermore, Spencer's detailed accounts of his own perceived slights—ranging from disputes over funeral arrangements to grievances about family dynamics—suggest a preoccupation with settling old scores rather than providing a balanced narrative. His portrayal of himself as a perpetual victim, juxtaposed with his criticisms of others, creates a narrative that feels more self-indulgent than enlightening.

Critics have noted that while the memoir offers some valuable insights into Diana's life, it is often overshadowed by Spencer's personal animosities. The Guardian describes the book as a "furious exercise in score-settling," highlighting the author's tendency to place himself at the center of the narrative. Similarly, The Week points out the memoir's focus on Spencer's grievances, suggesting that it serves more as a platform for his own resentments than a tribute to his sister.

In conclusion, "Swan Song: Diana, My Sister" is a frustrating read. While it holds the potential to offer a poignant remembrance of Princess Diana, it is marred by the author's apparent need to settle personal scores. Readers seeking an unbiased and heartfelt tribute to Diana may find themselves disappointed by the memoir's self-serving tone.

Recommendation: Not recommended.

written on: 10/1/2026